Bright Star

Beautifully expressed love story. The romance of John Keats and Fanny Brawne plays out on screen with gentleness and restraint.

Keats is a legend among English poets (A thing of beauty is a joy forever…), and most of us are at least a little familiar with his work. He died young, of tuberculosis, but in the years before his death he was consumed by a great passion for young Fanny. It was not a popular match: Keats’ friends didn’t trust the young woman, believing her to be fickle and a flirt, and her mother could not approve an engagement to a penniless poet. None of this stopped the young lovers, however, and writer/director Jane Campion shows, with great believability, the inevitability of their romance. There are no Hollywood contrivances here, no “meet cute” scenes where snappy sarcastic dialogue signals that a couple will get together in the end. Fanny and John’s courtship proceeds slowly, frequently chaperoned by her young siblings, and it is the children’s reactions that often telegraph the significance of the lovers’ exchanges, necessarily subdued in Victorian England. Campion is very good at this, animating her story with supporting characters that, with an expression or subtle gesture, shine a light on a small but important moment in a scene.

One of the intriguing things about Fanny and John’s love story is that its details were unknown for decades following Keats’ death. Fanny mourned for years but finally moved on, marrying and having a family of her own. However, unbeknownst to her husband, she kept Keats’ ardent love letters, and her children arranged for them to be published after their parents’ deaths. These letters form the basis of much of Campion’s story, and she pulls whole lines of dialogue from them, providing a sense of authenticity that often goes missing when period films try to attract a modern audience. Keats’ poems are also included, but organically, read and discussed by Keats’ peers and shared between John and Fanny, even though she says plainly that she doesn’t always understand them. However, Campion makes sure Fanny gets credit for being more than an object of affection and desire: the young woman designs and makes all her own clothing; she is often shown stitching or sketching, an artist in her own right.

Tremendous performances all around: Abbie Cornish as Fanny is luminous but steely – you easily believe she would pursue her passion regardless of obstacles. Ben Whishaw inhabits Keats with all his dramatic artistry. And Kerry Fox plays Fanny’s conflicted mother with simple, beautiful, humanity. There are moments in Bright Star that are heartbreakingly romantic, and others that are heartbreakingly sad, but you never feel manipulated. It's fair to say that this film runs long but it is very good, and it will stay with you after you leave the theater. Playing all across the country. Definite Oscar bait, most likely in the acting and costume categories.